Faith Over Flapjacks: Cook Wins $40K After Refusing Sunday Shift

Eddie Moton Jr., a cook at an IHOP in South Carolina, stood firm in his faith. Hired in 2021, he was granted a religious accommodation to keep Sundays sacred. But when new management demanded he work two Sundays, he refused, clinging to his beliefs. The price? His job.

Moton’s firing sparked a legal battle that ended with a $40,000 settlement in his favor. The case has now set a precedent, compelling the franchise owner, Suncakes, to overhaul its policies. Annual training on religious liberty will be mandatory for managers, and all employees will be informed of their rights regarding religious accommodations.

The former manager’s dismissive attitude towards Moton’s beliefs stirred controversy. He reportedly told other staff that “religion should not take precedence” and mocked Moton’s choice to attend church over work, saying he “thinks it is more important to go to church than to pay his bills.”

Taittiona Miles, the lead attorney in the case, was clear in her defense of Moton’s rights. “Employers must respect all sincerely held religious beliefs, which includes providing reasonable accommodations when no undue hardship exists,” she stated.

This ruling echoes broader protections under federal law, as Melinda Dugas from the US Equal Employment Opportunity Commission emphasized. She reminded employers that requesting religious accommodation is a protected right, and retaliation for exercising it is unlawful.

In a similar vein, UK laws also protect workers’ rights to avoid Sunday shifts if they conflict with their religious practices. The Moton case serves as a reminder to businesses everywhere that respect for religious beliefs isn’t just a courtesy—it’s the law.